AGV-SOLUTIONS GMBH

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Answers about mobile robotics, automated guided vehicle (AGV) systems and manufacturer-independent consulting

AGV-Solutions GmbH, based in Kirchheim unter Teck (Stuttgart region, Germany), provides manufacturer-independent consulting on the planning, tendering, introduction and optimisation of automated guided vehicle (AGV) systems and mobile robotics. On this page we answer the questions our customers ask most often.

Independent consulting

An AGV system is an investment for many years – vehicles, fleet management system, interfaces and processes must fit together over the long term. A manufacturer-independent consultant represents only your interests: they clarify the requirements, compare solutions from different suppliers objectively and make sure the contract specifies what you actually need. Your first AGV project in particular sets the course – this is where costly wrong decisions should be avoided.

You get a solution that fits your processes – not a supplier’s product portfolio. Specifically: a clear requirements specification, comparable offers, a realistic budget and schedule, fewer change orders and a system that remains expandable and manufacturer-independent in the long term (e.g. via the VDA 5050 communication standard). As an independent partner, we also challenge your own requirements instead of simply answering every requirement with “we can do that”. Simple adjustments to processes or load carriers often avoid expensive special solutions. The cost of consulting is usually a small part of the total investment.

A good supplier is an important success factor – independent support does not change that. We complement the supplier on your side: we check whether the offer matches your requirements, pay attention to interfaces, safety and acceptance criteria and support your team throughout the project. Many projects go well precisely because someone with AGV experience on the customer side talks to the supplier as an equal.

A good business relationship is valuable – and it remains. However, a dealer naturally offers solutions from its own portfolio. Whether these are the best choice for your application can only be judged by comparison and with good market knowledge. We create this comparability without straining the relationship: your dealer is of course welcome to submit an offer and is evaluated by the same criteria as everyone else.

Many companies are implementing an AGV system for the first time – the supplier does it every day. We bring more than 30 years of experience in logistics, production and factory planning, including many years as head of conveyor technology planning and AGV strategy at Mercedes-Benz Cars. Our experience comes from more than 30 AGV projects in more than 12 countries on 4 continents with a total of around 550 vehicles. We know the typical pitfalls from tendering to acceptance. You can also involve us selectively, for example for a concept review, the requirements specification or commissioning.

Suitability and technology

That depends on your transport tasks: how many transports are there, how regular are they, in how many shifts, and how much staff do they tie up today? An AGV system pays off especially with recurring transports, staff shortages, multi-shift operation and high demands on transparency and process reliability. In an initial meeting and a short potential analysis, we clarify whether and where automation is worthwhile for you.

Many processes are more suitable than you might think – some need minor adjustments, for example at transfer stations, load carriers, routes or floor conditions. We analyse your material flows, quantity structures and existing infrastructure and show which transports can be automated with reasonable effort and where automation is not (yet) worthwhile.

The mobile robotics market is large and developing quickly – from underride robots and automated forklifts to special vehicles for heavy loads. For most applications there are several suitable suppliers; for special cases, solutions can be combined or adapted. We know the market across manufacturers and tell you openly which suppliers are suitable for your task – and if there is no suitable solution (yet), we tell you that too.

Automated guided vehicle systems have been in industrial use for decades and are proven for many applications. Newer technologies such as autonomous mobile robots (AMRs), open interfaces (VDA 5050) and cross-manufacturer fleet management systems make solutions even more flexible. Waiting rarely pays off: if you start today with a manageable pilot area, you gain experience and can expand the system step by step later. It is important to ensure expandability and manufacturer independence from the outset.

Not always. For a single vehicle or a few simple transport routes, a simple solution without a higher-level fleet management system may be sufficient. As soon as several vehicles work together, different vehicle types or manufacturers are used, or orders come from ERP or warehouse management systems, a fleet management system is usually indispensable – for order allocation, traffic control, battery charging and transparency. We recommend the simplest solution that reliably meets your requirements and does not block future expansion.

This is usually decided in the very first project. Proprietary systems can generally only be expanded with the original supplier – and not every manufacturer has all vehicle types in its portfolio. If a transport task is added later for which your supplier has no suitable vehicle, things quickly become expensive or impossible. That is why we consider which expansions might follow right from the first application and keep these options open for you through the right system selection – for example via open interfaces such as VDA 5050 and a cross-manufacturer fleet management system.

Cost-effectiveness and operation

This can only be answered reliably on the basis of your figures. The decisive factors are the number and regularity of transports, the number of shifts, the staff capacity saved or redeployed, and investment and operating costs. In multi-shift operation, AGV systems often pay for themselves very quickly – frequently in less than 18 months. When selecting a system, we take into account not only the investment but also service, maintenance and running costs over the entire service life – the cheapest offer is not automatically the most economical solution. We prepare a transparent cost-effectiveness analysis as the basis for your decision.

Yes – with the right preparation. Modern AGV systems are designed for low-maintenance operation; after training, your own staff take over many tasks such as troubleshooting, battery care and simple maintenance. It is important to specify training, documentation, spare parts and service agreements in the tender. We make sure that your team can operate the system safely after handover.

Working with us

The initial consultation including a site visit is always free of charge. We always get a picture on site – not via video conference. Afterwards, we give you an assessment of suitability and feasibility and propose a suitable approach, tailored to the status of your project.

In all of them – preferably early, when concepts are being developed and the course is being set. We support tendering and contract award, and in award negotiations we use our market knowledge and reference values to identify good starting points for savings. During commissioning, our experience and systematic approach help – especially since many suppliers have only recently started building AGVs or AMRs and have little implementation experience. We also optimise existing systems, support upgrades, replacements and system changes for legacy installations, and act as mediator when projects have reached a deadlock.

Your question was not answered here?

Get in touch – the initial consultation including an on-site visit is free of charge.